When my daughter got her first car, she wanted to find the cheapest car insurance rate online—but with so many options, she didn’t know where to start. Instead of settling for the first quote she found, she took her time to shop around, compare multiple providers, and saved over $400 per year on her policy.

If you’re looking for the best way to shop around for car insurance rates online, this guide will help you:
✅ Understand how online car insurance shopping works
✅ Compare multiple quotes efficiently
✅ Find discounts to lower your premium even further

---

Why Shop for Car Insurance Online?

Shopping for car insurance online lets you:
✔️ Compare multiple quotes in minutes.
✔️ Save hundreds of dollars by finding the lowest price.
✔️ Customize coverage based on your needs.
✔️ Avoid dealing with pushy sales agents.

🚗 Example: My daughter got quotes from five different providers, and the cheapest option was $35/month less than the most expensive one. Over a year, that added up to $420 in savings!

---

Best Websites to Compare Car Insurance Quotes Online

We tested the most popular car insurance comparison websites to find the best ones for shopping around.

Comparison Website	Best For	How Many Quotes?	Estimated Time to Compare
The Zebra	Best overall comparison tool	100+ companies	5 minutes
NerdWallet	Best for bundling home & auto	50+ companies	5 minutes
Policygenius	Best for finding discounts	40+ companies	7 minutes
Gabi	Best for checking if you’re overpaying	20+ companies	3 minutes
Compare.com	Best for fast estimates	60+ companies	5 minutes

📌 Quick Breakdown:

• The Zebra & NerdWallet: Best for getting the most quotes quickly.
• Policygenius: Best if you want to maximize discounts.
• Gabi: Best if you already have insurance and want to check for cheaper rates.
• Compare.com: Best if you want fast, estimated rates before entering details.

🚗 Example: My daughter used The Zebra and found that GEICO’s online policy was $40/month cheaper than Progressive for the same coverage.

---

Step-by-Step Guide: How to Shop for the Cheapest Car Insurance Online

Step 1: Gather Your Information 📋

Before comparing quotes, have the following ready:
✔️ Driver’s license number
✔️ Vehicle details (make, model, year, VIN)
✔️ Current insurance policy (if switching)
✔️ Mileage driven per year
✔️ Driving history (tickets, accidents, claims)

🚗 Example: My daughter made sure she had all her details before shopping around, so the process was fast and hassle-free.

---

Step 2: Compare Quotes from Multiple Providers 🏆

Instead of getting a quote from one company, use comparison sites to get multiple estimates at once.

📌 Best Comparison Tools:
✔️ The Zebra (Most quotes)
✔️ Policygenius (Best discounts)
✔️ Gabi (Best if you already have insurance)

🚗 Example: My daughter checked quotes from five companies and GEICO was $480/year cheaper than State Farm.

---

Step 3: Customize Your Coverage to Find the Best Price ⚖️

📌 Choose Between Full Coverage & Liability-Only:

Coverage Type	Best For	Estimated Monthly Cost
Full Coverage	New or financed cars	$100 – $250
Liability-Only	Older cars (10+ years)	$50 – $120

🚗 Example: Since my daughter’s car was worth less than $6,000, she chose liability-only coverage, cutting her premium by 50%.

---

Step 4: Apply Discounts to Lower Your Quote 💰

Most insurance companies offer automatic discounts, but you may need to select them manually.

✔️ Good driver discount – Save 10-30% if you have no tickets or accidents.
✔️ Low-mileage discount – Save 5-15% if you drive under 7,500 miles per year.
✔️ Multi-policy discount – Save 10-25% by bundling home & auto insurance.
✔️ Good student discount – If under 25 with a GPA of 3.0+, save 10-20%.
✔️ Pay-in-full discount – Save 5-10% by paying 6 months upfront.

🚗 Example: My daughter’s good student discount + safe driver discount saved her $250 per year.

---

Step 5: Adjust Your Deductible for More Savings 💳

A higher deductible means lower monthly payments, but you’ll pay more if you file a claim.

📌 Potential Savings:

• Raising the deductible from $500 to $1,000 saves 10-15% per year.
• Raising it from $1,000 to $2,500 saves 15-20% per year.

🚗 Example: My daughter raised her deductible from $500 to $1,000, reducing her premium by $200 per year.

---

Step 6: Purchase & Get Instant Proof of Insurance ✅

Once you find the best quote, you can buy your policy online and get instant proof of insurance via email or the insurance company’s mobile app.

📌 Where to Buy Car Insurance Online Instantly:
✔️ GEICO, Progressive, State Farm, and Allstate allow you to buy coverage online in minutes.
✔️ Esurance specializes in quick, online-only policies.
✔️ Metromile & Allstate Milewise offer pay-per-mile policies if you drive less.

🚗 Example: My daughter bought her policy online with GEICO, got instant proof of insurance, and was covered in less than 15 minutes.

---

Final Thoughts: How My Daughter Found the Cheapest Online Car Insurance

After shopping around online, my daughter chose GEICO because:
✅ It had the lowest premium for liability-only coverage.
✅ She qualified for a good student & safe driver discount.
✅ She raised her deductible to lower her monthly payments.

💰 Final Cost:
✔️ Before Shopping Around: $140/month
✔️ After Comparing Quotes & Applying Discounts: $95/month
✔️ Total Savings: $540 per year

🚗 Bottom Line: If you want cheap car insurance online, the best way to save money is to:
✔️ Use a quote comparison tool (The Zebra, NerdWallet, etc.).
✔️ Choose the right coverage for your car’s value.
✔️ Apply all available discounts (safe driver, good student, bundling, etc.).
✔️ Raise your deductible to lower your premium.
✔️ Buy online and get instant proof of coverage.

By shopping around online, my daughter saved over $500 per year on car insurance—and you can too! 🚗💰💻