As a family with multiple vehicles, my husband and I knew we needed to find a way to save on car insurance while keeping each car fully covered. We discovered that multi-car insurance policies not only simplify coverage but also come with big discounts for insuring more than one car under the same provider.

If you have two or more vehicles in your household, this guide will help you:
✅ Understand how multi-car insurance works
✅ Find the best companies offering multi-car discounts
✅ Get the cheapest multi-car insurance quotes

---

How Does Multi-Car Insurance Work?

📌 Multi-car insurance allows you to cover two or more vehicles under a single policy, saving money and simplifying billing.

✔️ One policy covers multiple cars, reducing paperwork.
✔️ Each car can have different coverage options (liability-only vs. full coverage).
✔️ A multi-car discount applies to each vehicle, lowering your premium.

🚗 Example:

• Before bundling, we had two separate car insurance policies:
  • Car 1: $120/month
  • Car 2: $110/month
  • Total Cost: $230/month
• After switching to multi-car insurance, our premium dropped to $190/month, saving $480 per year!

---

Best Insurance Companies for Multi-Car Policies

We compared insurance providers to find the best companies for multi-car discounts and affordability.

Insurance Company	Best For	Multi-Car Discount	Estimated Monthly Cost (2 Cars)
GEICO	Cheapest multi-car insurance	25%	$170 – $230
State Farm	Best for families with teen drivers	20%	$180 – $240
Progressive	Best for high-risk drivers	15%	$190 – $250
Allstate	Best bundling discounts (home & auto)	22%	$185 – $245
USAA	Best for military families	25%	$160 – $220
Nationwide	Best for customizable coverage	20%	$175 – $235

📌 Quick Breakdown:

• GEICO & USAA: Best for lowest multi-car insurance rates.
• State Farm: Best for families with teen drivers.
• Progressive: Best for drivers with accidents or violations.
• Allstate: Best for bundling auto & home insurance for extra savings.
• Nationwide: Best for customizing different coverage options for multiple vehicles.

🚗 Example: My husband and I compared GEICO vs. State Farm, and GEICO saved us $40/month on a multi-car policy.

---

How to Get the Cheapest Multi-Car Insurance Quotes

1. Compare Quotes from Multiple Providers 📊

Insurance rates vary, and each company calculates multi-car discounts differently, so comparing quotes is the best way to find savings.

📌 Best Websites to Compare Multi-Car Insurance Quotes:

• The Zebra
• NerdWallet
• Policygenius

🚗 Example: My husband used The Zebra and found that GEICO was $30/month cheaper than Allstate for our two-car policy.

---

2. Take Advantage of Stacking Discounts 💰

Beyond multi-car discounts, insurers offer additional savings that lower your premium even further.

✔️ Multi-policy discount – Save 10-25% by bundling home & auto insurance.
✔️ Good driver discount – Save 10-30% if you have a clean record.
✔️ Low-mileage discount – Save 5-15% if you drive under 7,500 miles per year.
✔️ Good student discount – If you have a teen driver with a 3.0 GPA or higher, save 10-20%.
✔️ Pay-in-full discount – Pay 6 months or a year upfront to save 5-10%.

🚗 Example: By bundling our auto and home insurance, we saved an extra 15%—totaling $250 per year in additional savings.

---

3. Adjust Coverage Based on Each Car 🚗

Each vehicle doesn’t need the same level of coverage—adjusting coverage per car can save you money.

📌 How to Adjust Coverage for Multiple Cars:

Car Type	Recommended Coverage	Why?
Newer Car (Less than 5 years old)	Full Coverage (Comprehensive + Collision)	Protects against accidents, theft, & damage
Older Car (10+ years old)	Liability-Only	Full coverage may not be worth the cost
Teen’s Car	Full Coverage + Higher Deductible	Keeps them covered while lowering the monthly premium

🚗 Example: My husband drives an older truck, so we switched it to liability-only insurance, saving $400 per year while keeping full coverage on my newer SUV.

---

4. Consider Raising Your Deductible 💳

A higher deductible means lower monthly payments.

📌 Potential Savings:

• Raising your deductible from $500 to $1,000 saves 10-15% on premiums.
• Raising it from $1,000 to $2,500 saves 15-20%.

🚗 Example: We raised our deductible from $500 to $1,000, reducing our multi-car premium by $200 per year.

---

5. Ask About Usage-Based or Pay-Per-Mile Insurance 🚦

If one of your vehicles is driven less, consider a pay-per-mile insurance plan to reduce costs.

📌 Best Pay-Per-Mile Insurance Providers:
✔️ Metromile – Best for low-mileage drivers.
✔️ Allstate Milewise – Great for occasional drivers.
✔️ Nationwide SmartMiles – Best for remote workers.

🚗 Example: My husband only drives his second car on weekends, so pay-per-mile insurance saved us $300 per year on that vehicle.

---

Final Thoughts: How My Husband and I Found the Cheapest Multi-Car Insurance

After comparing multiple quotes, we chose GEICO because:
✅ It had the lowest multi-car discount (25%).
✅ We bundled auto & home insurance, saving an extra 15%.
✅ We switched one car to liability-only coverage and raised our deductible.

💰 Final Cost:
✔️ Before Bundling & Adjustments: $230/month for 2 cars
✔️ After Bundling & Adjustments: $190/month
✔️ Total Savings: $480 per year

🚗 Bottom Line: If you need affordable multi-car insurance, the best way to lower your costs is to:
✔️ Compare quotes from multiple providers.
✔️ Stack additional discounts (bundling, good driver, low mileage, etc.).
✔️ Adjust coverage based on each vehicle’s needs.
✔️ Raise deductibles to lower premiums.
✔️ Consider usage-based insurance for rarely driven cars.

By bundling our vehicles into a single policy, my husband and I saved nearly $500 per year—and you can too! 🚗🚗💰